All Froth And No Substance

Save Malaysia, Stop Lying

The very name – SAVE MALAYSIA STOP LYNAS (SMSL) – speaks volumes: it openly declares its deceitfulness as a ‘purpose-specific’ opposition organisation bent only on thwarting the genuine efforts of the good people of Gebeng and the Lynas project in Malaysia; it implies the Lynas project is a threat to the very existence of Malaysia, a preposterous claim devoid of any rationale and one incapable of reconciliation in the mind of any reasonable person.

SMSL’s objective runs contrary to that of the Malaysian Government whose stated aim is to place the country in an enviable position as the high-tech hub of Asia; to encourage companies at the cutting edge of technology to operate in Malaysia, developing the economy, providing satisfying careers, increasing the country’s Gross Domestic Product and improving living standards and quality of life for all citizens.

The government enticed Lynas to Malaysia by offering taxation incentives, with assurances that the country was ready to embrace such a project, with all the necessary infrastructure and a trained workforce in place.

It led Lynas to build its plant at Gebeng where petro-chemical, chemical and other similar types of industries are located.  The plant is no closer to residential areas than any of these existing industries which have also proved to be no danger to the community.

Without exception, Lynas complied with all conditions of approval imposed by the AELB, which is the authority with approval responsibility.  The AELB, in its diligence and care for the people of Malaysia, even applied additional rigorous compliance and safety checks on the project by calling for the International Atomic Energy Authority, as the independent world nuclear safety authority, to investigate and provide any and all recommendations necessary to ensure the safety of the operation.  Its basic finding was that the project safety standard is world’s Best Practice.

Lynas complied with the IAEA’s additional requirements, then went even further than that by installing 2 instruments to measure radioactivity levels.  These instruments automatically supply live readings to the internet – their installation is further explicit proof of the safety of the project.

After these exhaustive, time consuming investigations, the AELB eventually approved the necessary Temporary Operating Licence, allowing production to commence.

Through all these steps, SMSL with Fuziah Salleh prominently in the lead, has had ample opportunity to submit its objections and to voice its concerns.  It has not missed any chance to do so, focusing endlessly on toxic radioactivity, ‘Fukushima-type’ disasters, dangerously radioactive waste material escaping into the environment and so on.

These objections have all been given serious and due consideration by highly qualified relevant experts and found to be unsound scientifically and therefore in due course the SMSL claims were rightfully disregarded.

Let me say that again: SMSL presented all the evidence it has to the AELB and that information has been so un-compelling, the AELB has given its decision against SMSL and in favour of Lynas.

SMSL has been stubbornly unwilling and unable to accept that decision from the AELB, the Government body charged with the responsibility, expertise and authority to make that comprehensive and informed decision on behalf of the citizens of Malaysia.  Instead, it has continued to rant and rave emotionally about toxic radioactivity and impending apocalyptic doom for Malaysia.  It has taken court action to impede further progress.

Clearly, the only decision that will satisfy them is one that will see no operation ever in the Lynas plant.

They claim to want to save Malaysia from being destroyed by Lynas.  In all their evidence to the inquiries, they have been unable to produce any scientific evidence to justify this emotional, hysterical claim.  Nor has any reputable scientist independently been able to offer any facts to support their claims.  It is clear to impartial observers (many of them around the world are watching in amazement) that they have no case, yet they have continued making the same claims which have already been rejected a number of times.

Their leadership must have some intelligence.  Fuziah Salleh is a member of Parliament and I presume her brain is capable of discerning fact from fiction.  Jade Lee, another “leader” in the anti-Lynas group is university educated and should have some intellectual capacity although she often gives no indication of it, arguing with a fair degree of vitriol.

So there would be a number of reasonably intelligent people in the SMSL organisation who understand that their claims about the danger of the Lynas plant to the community and nation are unfounded.

Knowing they are in the wrong, they nevertheless have willfully and hypocritically continued their opposition, claiming the high moral ground.  So why have they done that?  Why have they not accepted the highly regarded AELB’s decision?

The answer is they are playing politics.  This has nothing to do with safe-guarding the health of the population and the environment (the approval process has already achieved that).  It has everything to do with the upcoming election.

There is no risk whatever to the community from Lynas’s plant which has been acknowledged as the safest, most advanced plant of its type in the world.  It will operate safely and be the leading edge of Malaysia’s push towards high technology leadership in Asia.

Shame on you, SMSL.  Shame on you, Fuziah Salleh.  Instead of your own interests, it’s time for you to put those of Malaysia first. - Read More